更全的杂志信息网

Initial residual stress experiment and simulation of thin-walled parts for layer removal method①

更新时间:2016-07-05

0 Introduction

The problem of residual stress has always been much concerned. In the process of casting, forging, welding and cutting, unequal plastic deformation caused by force and temperature variation is the main reason for residual stress[1-4] which has a direct influence on mechanical properties, resistance to stress corrosion, fatigue strength, dimensional stability and service life of workpiece. Most countries have conducted long-term research[5]. Measuring methods of residual stress can be currently divided into two categories: physical method consists mainly of X-ray diffraction, ultrasonic, magnetic strain, etc.; mechanical method consists mainly of layer cutting, trepanning or drilling, etc[6]. However, most residual stress measurement technologies are only suitable for measuring residual stress of surface or shallow surface. It is difficult to ensure the accuracy of inside workpiece[7] of residual stress measurement. Europe, the United States and other countries have studied neutron method and hard X-ray method which could directly measure triaxial residual stress distribution inside thick plate, but currently these technologies are only used in laboratory study[8,9].

熊耳群作为基底岩系的盖层,在区内出露面积较大,由一套中基性火山岩组成,自下而上分为许山组、鸡蛋坪组、马家河组三个岩组,与下伏太华群呈角度不整合接触。其中鸡蛋坪组为本区主要金矿赋存围岩。

The layer removal is a method for measuring internal residual stress of workpiece which mills the material from workpiece surface and measures the residual stress value of each exposed surface. Elastic mechanics method is used to calculate stress revision value after layer removal, and further obtaining the value before layer removal inside the workpiece. According to the existing revision theories, the layer removal method applies to cylindrical, circular tube of great axial-diameter ratio and plate with great width-thickness ratio[10]. In practical application, the method is mostly used in combination with X-ray method. However, new cutting residual stress in milling process would be produced. And the coupling effect with the initial residual stress of blank often falsifies the measurement result. That needs further study.

The aim of the present work is to study the reliability and accuracy of layer removal method. According to experimental results of initial residual stress for casting ZL205A aluminum alloy tapered thin-walled blank, the finite element model with initial residual stress is established to simulate the experimental process by using a birth and death element method and milling simulation method. Then error and the rationality of layer removal method have been analyzed by comparing the simulation with the experiment.

50例阴茎鳞状细胞癌患者,均以术后行18F-FDG PET/CT显像检查为起始时间,每隔3个月为随访时间节点进行为期1年的随访。对怀疑复发和转移的病灶行手术切除活检或穿刺活检,病理确诊为阳性的患者结束随访,本研究所选病例均如期完成随访。

1 Initial residual stress experiment

In the existing methods, the hole-drilling method is more mature. This method is more commonly used in Engineering, because of its easiness of operation, cheapness of equipments, small damage area of workpiece, and high precision[11,12].

1.1 研究对象 回顾性分析遂宁市第一人民医院自2013年2月至2017年12月收治的563例阴道分泌物疑似支原体感染的女性患者的临床资料。患者年龄18~65岁,平均年龄(37.40±6.15)岁。本研究经医院伦理委员会批准,患者均签署知情同意书。

Andersen[13] improved the hole-drilling method, in which drilling depth was increased gradually to determine strain values of strain gauge film gate at different depths. Furthermore the principal stress values at each depth were calculated based on these strain values. Eq.(1) is as follows:

珍惜土地资源 建设美丽家园 .............................................................................................................................6-1

(1)

where, i refers to the number of increments drilled, j is the increment in which the stress is acting, is strain value of strain gauge at each depth, σ1j and σ2j are principal stresses within increment j, aij and bij are unit stress release coefficients, βj is the angle measured counter-clockwise from the direction of principal stresses and strain gauge.

1.1 Experiment process

In the experiment, ZL205A casting aluminum alloy tapered thin-walled blank of 50mm in small end diameter, 300mm in big end diameter, 850mm in length and 32mm in thickness is used. Hole-drilling equipment is HTZ-12 omnipotence precision drilling device shown in Fig.1. Detection device is HT21B portable digital residual stress detector shown in Fig.2. A 1.5mm diameter hole in a typical measurement point of workpiece is drilled and a compensation plate is pasted on the position away from the measuring point to compensate for strain changes caused by temperature. The measurement and compensation position is shown in Fig.3.

对于给定赛题的大赛来说,赛题的难度要考虑目前大学生在校的学习情况来确定,一些赛题的难度过高,国内的相关技术资料较少,留给学生学习的空间有限,学生需要从国外的网站才能找到一些资料,这类题目应该尽量避免。另外,可以将赛题进行必要的划分,一些动手能力较强的,理论要求不高的题目可以由高职类的学生来完成。一些需要一定理论基础和优化算法较复杂的题目,可以由本科学生完成,这样进一步保障学生学习状况和赛题的匹配性和针对性。

Fig.1 HTZ-12 omnipotence precision drilling device

In the simulation, the workpiece should achieve mesh refinement and the tool should reduce mesh, which not only ensures accuracy of results but also saves solution time and memory consumption. The mesh of workpiece is divided into 50,280 elements. Element type is an 8-node hexahedral three-dimensional reduced integral unit (C3D8RT). The mesh of tool is divided into 1134 elements. Element type is tetrahedral element (R3D4). The assembly drawing of tool and workpiece is shown in Fig.14. To be consistent with the finite element model of birth and death element method, milling speed is set to 3000r/min, milling depth is 2mm, and feed rate is 300mm/min.

①海南省的旅游经济与生态环境的评价指数呈现相反的变化趋势,2005—2015年旅游经济评价指数总体大幅度上升,生态环境评价指数则波动下降;②两系统的耦合协调度呈现出上升的趋势,协调类型由濒临失调逐渐过渡到中级协调,并保持稳定状态,增长方式由旅游经济滞后型转变为生态环境滞后型,并呈现旅游经济与生态环境同步发展型的良好态势。

As shown in Fig.4, initial residual stress of the blank is mainly distributed in the range of 6mm below the surface. When the thickness is greater than 6mm, residual stress values of x and y directions become smaller. The stress is compressive stress in the thickness ranging from 2mm to 4mm and tensile stress in the thickness ranging from 4mm to 6mm, which makes the blank in a state of stress balance.

Fig.2 HT21B portable digital residual stress detector

Fig.3 Hole-drilling position

1.2 Experimental results

Because of the same surface technology in casting, residual stress of the blank is central symmetrical distribution in the thickness direction. It only needs to measure experiment values of 2-16mm in the thickness. Drilling eight times in the measurement point, the thickness is respective 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16 mm. At the end of each drilling, strain values of the point are obtained and then the residual stress in each thickness is calculated by Eq.(1) as shown in Table 1 and Fig.4.

Table 1 Experimental results of initial residual stress

Thickness(mm)Thestressinx⁃direction(MPa)Thestressiny⁃direction(MPa)2-114.7669-105.73674-8.78400.1401631.987134.515886.16136.1554103.32021.616712-1.6383-2.068614-4.5229-4.086816-2.4770-2.4770

周小羽的一顿皮肉之苦自然是免不了的,尽管李老师一直说不要打他不要打他,但在李老师出门后,周小羽被打了个结结实实。这一顿打,周小羽就在家里休息了一星期,这个星期里周小羽就是趴在床上,他的屁股没有碎成四瓣,却肿成了两个大馒头,他的背上,他的腿上都画上了红红紫紫的印子。

Fig.4 Residual stress curve in the thickness

2 Numerical modeling procedure by birth and death element method

where ap is axial cutting depth (mm), v is milling speed (m/min), f is feed rate (mm/min), aw is radial cutting depth (mm) and d is cutter diameter (mm).

从全国文学界来看,按照反映知青生活的地域划分,在全国响当当的代表作家大概有以下几位:东北有梁晓声、张抗抗,陕北有史铁生,内蒙有张贤亮,云南有叶辛等。这些作家大多出生于北京、上海、杭州等大城市。上山下乡带来的巨大生活反差,使他们对现实充满无奈,对未来充满迷茫,对命运充满恐惧。他们的作品反映的是一群人、一代人在那个特定生活环境里的情感、思想与行为方式。然而,如前所说,偌大一个中原,将近一百万的知青,历时25年的上山下乡,却没有多少文学作品去直面中原知青生活,而引起全国关注的文学作品更是凤毛麟角。从这个角度上讲,《沱河记忆》的典型意义就更大了。

2.1 FiniteelementmodelinANSYS

In the finite element simulation, in order to improve the computational efficiency and easily apply for birth and death element method, the structure of the model is simplified to a rectangle of 200mm×200mm×32mm as shown in Fig.5. The material property of ZL205A aluminium alloy is assigned to the model. Density is 2.8g/cm3. Young’s modulus is 68GPa. Poisson ratio is 0.33. Yield stress is 455Mpa. The eight-node hexahedron SOLID185 is used to discretize the model. In order to correspond with the experiment, the model is discretized into 16 layers and 2mm in each layer in the thickness direction.

Fig.5 Geometric model

2.2 Initial residual stress in ANASYS

Since the initial residual stress is not applied to a few faces, lines or points, but to the whole model, ANSYS parametric design language (APDL) is used to simplify the process of operation. According to residual stress test results, an IST file with initial residual stress data is generated by APDL, and then applied to corresponding element symmetrically. The flow chart of applying initial residual stress by APDL is shown in Fig.6. The model with initial residual stress in x-direction is shown as Fig.7, and in y-direction is shown as Fig.8.

Fig.6 Flow chart of generating an IST file

Fig.7 Initial residual stress of in x-direction

Fig.8 Initial residual stress in y-direction

2.3 Simulation parameters

According to the actual layer removal process, circular milling path is selected. As shown in Fig.9, the elements of three circular paths are gradually killed by using birth and death element method. A circular boss of 10 mm diameter is retained and the stress value is recorded in the boss. After recording, similarly, the elements of boss are killed. This process is repeated 16 times. The 2mm thickness elements are killed at one time. In Fig.10, when recording stress value, the x-direction average value of No. 1, 2, 3 node is set as x-direction measured value, and the y-direction average

(2)

In order to study the reliability and accuracy of the layer removal method, a three-dimensional finite element model with initial residual stress is established according to experimental results. In this model, birth and death element method of finite element analysis software ANSYS is used for simulation analysis. The birth and death element technique is the method of reactivated or killed element in the analysis. When cutter feed is to remove the material, the corresponding finite elementsare will be killed. The elements of the birth or death do not mean to add or remove element, but are multiplied by a very small reduction factor (default value is 1.0E-6) to make the element of mass, load, damping, strain and stress to 0. These removed elements would still show in the window. In order to prevent singular matrix, the stiffness is not set to 0.

The mathematical model between milling parameters and residual stress is shown in Eq.(2)[14]. In order to reduce the influence of milling residual stress on simulation results, reasonable cutting parameters are selected, in which milling speed is 3000r/min, milling depth is 2mm and feed rate is 300mm/min.

value of No. 3, 4, 5 node is set as y-direction measured value.

Fig.9 Sketch of simulation path

Fig.10  Sketch of data point

2.4 Simulation results using birth and death element method

The thickness of the finite element model is 32mm. At one time, the 2mm of each layer is killed. After one layer is killed, the stress value of boss is recorded. In simulation, residual stress distribution of the model is shown in Figs 11 and 12. According to the measurement method of Fig.10, the simulation results are shown in Table 2.

Fig.11 Residual stress of x-direction in simulation

Fig.12 Residual stress of y-direction in simulation

Table 2    Simulation results using birth and

death element method

Thickness(mm)Thestressinx⁃direction(MPa)Thestressiny⁃direction(MPa)2-114.77-105.744-8.780.14631.9934.5286.166.16103.321.6212-1.64-2.0714-4.52-4.0916-2.48-2.4818-2.54-2.7620-4.58-4.0322-1.602.31243.30-1.42266.166.002829.5534.0430-7.760.0832-105.17-100.73

3 Numerical modeling procedure by milling simulation method

3.1 FiniteelementmodelinABAQUS

ABAQUS software has its own CAD module, but it is still immature in comparison with professional CAD software. So some complicated models generally need to use software such as UG,Solidworks. for modeling, and are imported into the ABAQUS interface. In this paper, a tool is established in the Solidworks software, and then repaired by the geometric repair tool in the ABAQUS part module. As shown in Fig.13, tool is cemented carbide end-milling cutter of four edges, in which the diameter is 50mm, rake angle is 16°, clearance angle is 27°, and helix angle is 39°. The workpiece is a rectangle of 200mm×200mm×32mm. Because the structure is relatively simple, it can be directly established in the ABAQUS. In accordance with the actual clamping, the degrees of freedom of workpiece at its bottom are completely fixed to avoid the workpiece movement and rotation.

Fig.13 Geometric figure of tool

Fig.14 Assembly drawing

3.2 Initial residual stress in ABAQUS

In order to apply initial residual stress, the model is discretized into 2mm in thickness each layer. According to the experimental results of residual stress, in load module of ABAQUS, initial residual stress is applied to the model symmetrically. The model with initial residual stress is shown as Fig.15.

3.3 Simulation results using milling simulation method

In simulation, residual stress distribution of the model is shown in Figs 16 and 17. According to the measurement method of Fig.10, the simulation results are shown in Table 3.

Fig.15 Initial residual stress in ABAQUS

Fig.16 Residual stress of x-direction in simulation

Fig.17 Residual stress of y-directionin simulation

Table 3 Simulation results by using milling simulation method

Thickness(mm)Thestressinx⁃direction(MPa)Thestressiny⁃direction(MPa)2-205.45-170.814-90.62-0.47692.8548.46899.70178.3010119.7489.7012-71.95-48.5914-67.57-132.7016-45.34-55.0918-63.34-75.4220-40.02-46.00223.86-67.2424-118.75102.0426135.48107.242822.3352.1630-44.20-0.5632-148.20-105.80

4 Results and discussion

Figs 18 and 19 are the comparison between simulation results in ANSYS and experiment. Because of the birth and death method of ANSYS, cutting tool and cutting force are not considered. The residual stress values of simulation and experiment have little difference.

Fig.18 Comparison curves of residual stress in x-direction

Fig.19 Comparison curves of residual stress in y-direction

Figs 20 and 21 are the comparison between simulation results in ABAQUS and experiment. Because of

Fig.20 Comparison curves of residual stress in x-direction

Fig.21 Comparison curves of residual stress in y-direction

milling simulation method of ABAQUS, cutting tool and cutting force are considered. The residual stress values of simulation and experiment have much difference. When milling to the middle layer, the difference of the stress values of simulation and experiment is greater. Therefore, the cutting residual stress produced in the milling process has a great influence on the measurement results. Especially when milling to the middle layer, the factor of cutting residual stress in the measurement must be taken into consideration.

5 Conclusions

In the present work, according to initial residual stress experiment for casting ZL205A aluminum alloy tapered thin-walled blank by using hole-drilling method, three finite element models with initial residual stress are established to simulate layer removal process in ANSYS and ABAUQS software, making the following conclusions:

(1) The residual stress values have little difference between simulation results in ANSYS and experimental results. This is because the birth and death method of ANSYS does not consider cutting tool.

(2) The residual stress values have much difference between simulation results in ABAQUS and experimental results. The reason is that in milling simulation method of ABAQUS, new cutting residual stress is produced by the tool and cutting force.

(3) In ABAQUS, when milling to the middle layer, the stress values of simulation and experiment have great difference and the deviation is obvious.

(4) According to the comparison of simulation and experiment results, for the actual initial residual stress measurement of layer removal method, especially internal measurement, cutting residual stress generated during the milling process is an important influence on measurement results. Reducing cutting residual stress is helpful to improve accuracy of the method.

References

[ 1] Abvabi A, Rolfe B, Hodgson P D, et al. The influence of residual stress on a roll forming process[J]. InternationalJournalofMechanicalSciences, 2015, 101-102: 124-136

[ 2] Doremus L, Cormier J, Villechaise P, et al. Influence of residual stresses on the fatigue crack growth from surface anomalies in a nickel-based superalloy[J]. MaterialsScience & EngineeringA, 2015, 644: 234-246

[ 3] Luo K Y, Lu J Z, Wang Q W, et al. Residual stress distribution of Ti-6Al-4V alloy under different ns-LSP processing parameters[J]. AppliedSurfaceScience, 2013, 285(19): 607-615

[ 4] Jeyakumar M, Christopher T. Influence of residual stresses on failure pressure of cylindrical pressure vessels[J]. ChineseJournalofAeronautics, 2013, 26(6): 1415-1421

[ 5] Withers P J, Bhadeshia H K D H. Residual stress measurement techniques[J]. AdvancedMaterials & Processes, 2001, 159(8):30-33

[ 6] Yang Y F, Zhang Z, Li L, et al. Numerical simulation and test of bulk residual stress and machining distortion in aluminum alloy 7085[J]. ActaAeronauticaetAstronauticaSinica, 2014, 35(2): 574-581 (In Chinese)

[ 7] Park J U, An G B, Wan C W, et al. Residual stress measurement in an extra thick multi-pass weld using initial stress integrated inherent strain method[J]. MarineStructures, 2014, 39:424-437

[ 8] Wang S H, Zuo D W, Li X F, et al. A study on the theory and experiment of measuring the residual stresses distribution in thick pre-stretched aluminum plate 7050T7451[J]. JournalofAppliedSciences, 2005, 23(2): 192-195 (In Chinese)

[ 9] am A C L, Shi Z, Lin J, et al. Influences of residual stresses and initial distortion on springback prediction of 7B04-T651 aluminium plates in creep-age forming[J]. InternationalJournalofMechanicalSciences, 2015, 103: 115-126

[10] Huang H R. Research of the Distribution of 3D Residual Stress of Railway Axles [D]. Beijing: Beijing University of Technology, 2005. 1-14 (In Chinese)

[11] Shen W L, Chen J Q, Zhao G P. Elimination of residual stress of diesel engine cylinder body casting[J]. FoundryTechnology, 2004, 25(9): 689-690 (In Chinese)

[12] Bolsunovskiy S, Vermel V, Gubanov G, et al. Thin-walled part machining process parameters optimization based on finite-element modeling of workpiece vibrations[J]. ProcediaCirp, 2013, 8: 276-280

[13] Andersen L F. Residual Stresses and Deformations in Steel Structures [D]. Copenhagen: Technical University of Denmark, 2000. 125-137

[14] Wang L T. Study on Residual Stress and Distortion Theory of Aeronautica Frame Structure in the Milling [D]. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University, 2003. 13-40 (In Chinese)

随着市场竞争越来越激烈,企业自身需要不断发展,物资供应工作价值取向的首要任务已由过去的及时供应转变为安全、及时、经济。物资供应部门成为了降低企业成本,提高企业效率,增强企业市场竞争力的重要部门。降低物资储备,减少积压物资的产生就显得尤为重要。下面就企业物资造成的原因进行分析并提出改进对策。

ZanTao,GaoXiangsheng,ZhangYanlin,LiuYunan,WangMin
《High Technology Letters》2018年第1期文献

服务严谨可靠 7×14小时在线支持 支持宝特邀商家 不满意退款

本站非杂志社官网,上千家国家级期刊、省级期刊、北大核心、南大核心、专业的职称论文发表网站。
职称论文发表、杂志论文发表、期刊征稿、期刊投稿,论文发表指导正规机构。是您首选最可靠,最快速的期刊论文发表网站。
免责声明:本网站部分资源、信息来源于网络,完全免费共享,仅供学习和研究使用,版权和著作权归原作者所有
如有不愿意被转载的情况,请通知我们删除已转载的信息 粤ICP备2023046998号